fudan school of management released a list of dishonest students who were exempted from admissions, sparking heated discussions on how to make "exemptions" more scientific and reasonable?
2024-10-07
한어Русский языкEnglishFrançaisIndonesianSanskrit日本語DeutschPortuguêsΕλληνικάespañolItalianoSuomalainenLatina
cctv news, beijing, october 6 (china voice reporter zhou yifan) according to the china voice of china news "news horizontal" report, the official website of fudan university school of management recently released the "2024 fudan university school of management recommendation notice of admissions dishonesty list". the notice stated that according to the relevant provisions of the commitment letter signed by the pre-admitted students and the college, some students who unilaterally violated the relevant provisions of the commitment letter during the 2024 admissions selection process of the college have been dealt with to varying degrees. ten students were notified of dishonesty during the recommendation and selection process. the information included in the report included the undergraduate institution, major, and student name.
"recommending outstanding fresh undergraduate graduates to study for master's degrees without examination" has always been an important way for colleges and universities to select outstanding talents. however, the specific enrollment time and procedures are often determined by each school. there will be cases where places are wasted or students cannot enter the college of their choice. condition. how to optimize the system and make "recommendation and exemption" more scientific and reasonable?
the "notice on the dishonest list of recruitment exemptions from fudan university school of management in 2024" announced ten undergraduate students from the 25th class who have violated integrity. among them, four students committed extremely serious breaches of integrity during the recommendation and selection process, and their breach of trust seriously affected their personal credibility and harmed the interests of relevant colleges and other applicants; another six students had serious violations of integrity during the recommendation and selection process. serious breach of integrity. the announcement shows that these students come from peking university, tongji, shanghai finance and economics and other universities.
△fudan university’s 2024 and 2025 exemption regulations clearly require that “candidates should be cautious, honest and trustworthy when filling in their application form and accepting notification of admission. once they make their own choice and are determined to be admitted, they are not allowed to give up.”
how to determine the students’ dishonest behavior and its severity was not explained in the notice; fudan university also did not respond to this. check the 2024 and 2025 exemption regulations of fudan university, which clearly requires that "candidates should be cautious, honest and trustworthy when filling out their application form and accepting the admission notification. once they have made their own choices and been determined to be admitted, they are not allowed to give up." therefore, the above students are very likely to give up. it was because i gave up my place after being pre-admitted.
shao, a student who participated in fudan university's application for exemption this year, revealed that before issuing a proposed admission notice, the school's admissions office will confirm with the student multiple times whether he or she can accept admission. “i participated in fudan university’s summer camp in july this year and received an offer from youying. after that, the admissions office confirmed with me many times through emails or phone calls whether i agreed or gave up my application (exemption). therefore, graduate students cannot if you choose this school, you theoretically have multiple opportunities to give up. if you don’t explain the situation to the admissions office and then deliberately break the appointment, i think it is unreasonable; but if you explain your decision to give up in advance, i think it is your right to break the appointment, and it is also your right to give up. you can give the admissions office more time to respond.”
however, whether the names of these students should be published online has also triggered heated discussions. some commentators believe that "exemption" is a two-way choice between well-known universities and outstanding students. after students receive the admission notice, they can choose according to the corresponding situation, which will help students enter the school and major that suits them, and can also help universities improve the quality of running schools. attract students to choose; some netizens said that in the double selection of "rejection", it is possible for either party to be rejected. he himself was also rejected by his favorite school before the deadline.
△the official website of fudan university school of management released the "notice on the 2024 fudan university school of management's recommended dishonest admissions list"
in response to fudan’s announcement of the list, a person familiar with the matter revealed: “this announcement only targets individual students who have repeatedly communicated in advance but still engage in dishonest behavior and have a negative impact.” another netizen said that the students to be admitted to the school of management of fudan university the notice is an "iron offer", which means that as long as the notice is issued, admission will be guaranteed. at the same time, about three emails will be sent from the summer camp to the official admission, and a commitment letter needs to be signed each time. only in mid-september only students who regret their decision before the deadline for admission notification will be notified in the second half of the year.
shao said: "the double selection of fudan university and student summer camps is the so-called 'iron offer', which has been unanimously recognized by the postgraduate community. i think postgraduate study is a trade-off in a sense, and both sides should make it." to be honest and understand each other, if i encounter a better offer (admission notice), i will have enough time to choose to give up. if the student does not explain the situation in advance and directly breaks the appointment, it is understandable that the school will publish the list. "
what impact will it have on the "referral" work of colleges and universities if you get a place to be admitted but refuse it at the last moment? why do some students go back on their word at the last minute?
the reporter inquired about the relevant notices from the ministry of education on promotion and exemption and the promotion and exemption regulations of tsinghua university, peking university, fudan and other universities. there are strict requirements for student registration and schools to send proposed admission lists. taking fudan university's "referral" policy as an example, the list of recommended students to be admitted needs to be reviewed and approved by the school's graduate admissions leadership group and announced to the public. those who have no objections to the announcement will report to the ministry of education's admissions system. if a student rejects the intended admission, it means that the school will have to carry out "waitlist admission" and other work again.
△in the ministry of education’s relevant notice on promotion and exemption and the promotion and exemption regulations of tsinghua university, peking university, fudan and other universities, there are strict requirements for student registration and schools to send proposed admission lists.
a college teacher in jiangsu said that it is a waste in terms of student resources and school costs. the teacher gave an example: "i used to have a student who also wanted to apply for graduate school. i said you are sure to go and don't waste the admission quota. she did well in the interview, and in the end (the school) admitted her after being admitted, she later went to jnu, because the cost of enrolling again is relatively high, which means that you have to go to the second round or even the third round, and originally, for example, you were ranked tenth. i don’t need you, but if we recruit students again, i may not be able to recruit more than 20 students. the quality of students and the cost of enrollment will both be affected. it’s very unfair to the school.”
according to many students and parents who have experienced referrals and exemptions, the main reason for such situations is that the recommendation and acceptance methods for recommended students are formulated and announced by the recommending schools and accepting units in accordance with the relevant regulations of the ministry of education. in order to be able to to "lock in" outstanding students, there is often a time lag in the recruitment of various schools, which causes some students to lock in a "guaranteed" school in advance.
the parent of the student said to ms. xiang: "because they are not synchronized, unlike the college entrance examination. we had two schools at the same level at the time, and there was a time difference between them, which made us suffer a little. we were lucky that these two schools were of relatively high levels. it’s close, the admission time is (also) very close, so if i click ‘confirm’, it won’t affect me.”
chu zhaohui, a researcher at the chinese academy of educational sciences, believes that universities’ monopoly on high-quality students is also one of the reasons for this situation. “a small number of colleges and universities have a monopoly on high-quality students to a certain extent. some relatively disadvantaged colleges and universities may have their advantages in a certain subject or a certain professional direction. for this type of colleges and universities, relatively speaking, the rights are protected. it’s not enough. we still need to build an overall open, transparent, and two-way selection system that takes into account equal rights among different universities and achieves equal rights between students and universities as much as possible.”
a college teacher in jiangsu believes that it is difficult to find a perfect solution in the "best of the best" recruitment such as recommendation and exemption, but whether it is possible to consider making the application and recruitment policies more rigorous and reasonable. "for example, 211 colleges and universities are unified at the same time, and 985 colleges and universities are at the same time. in this case, they are relatively concentrated. then students can only choose one among 211 and one among 985. it can be balanced."
liu haifeng, director of the zhejiang university imperial examination science and examination research center, said that after issuing admission notices, some foreign schools will charge "reservation fees" and other methods to confirm whether students can enroll in order to prevent students from occupying the admission quota. time payment will be regarded as giving up admission. our country has made it clear that in the college entrance examination admission policy, it is strictly forbidden to link admission with fees. however, we can consider promoting the construction of an honest recruitment system from a top-level design and establishing a multi-round supplementary admission mechanism to protect the rights and interests of schools and other students.
"the purpose of postgraduate guarantee is to break the national unified examination method, comprehensively evaluate outstanding undergraduates, and admit students in multiple ways. under the existing mechanism, after students give up, there are no restrictive measures. guidance opinions should be issued and signed a letter of integrity must be stated in advance. for example, if a student is very good, even if he knows that he will go to other schools, the teacher still wants to recruit him. (schools and teachers) must also be mentally prepared. later (students) can be on the waiting list. when a certain time comes and the (admission list) has been reported, they should not give up." liu haifeng said.
for more exciting information, please download the "yangguang.com" client in the application market. news clues are welcome, and the 24-hour news reporting hotline is 400-800-0088; consumers can also make online complaints through the "woodpecker consumer complaint platform" of cctv.com. copyright statement: the copyright of this article belongs to cctv and may not be reproduced without authorization. please contact: [email protected] for reprinting. we will be held accountable for any disrespectful behavior.
