news

song jia has become a hot topic because of her appearance. not everyone can get this kind of treatment.

her face is bright and bright, with a typical chinese beauty temperament, as mellow as the earth mother.

beauty is talent, but as an actor, you can't just be beautiful. song jia herself said that an actor can't just play beauties. an actor's face belongs to the character, and he must play real people in life.

on september 27, she posted a farewell message to "when the mountain flowers are blooming", in which she played the role of teacher zhang guimei, a model of the times.

in the play, she not only strives to be close to teacher zhang in terms of image, but also works hard on performance, doing as much as possible from spirit to form, striving to let more people know the real teacher zhang.

her performance was a success, but before that the famous actor hai qing played zhang guimei in the movie "i am a mountain".

they are all excellent actors playing the same character, so they will inevitably be compared. so what are the similarities and differences in their performances?

image-wise, it's hard to tell the difference.

both actors are very malleable, and they tried their best to restore teacher zhang's hairstyle, clothing, temperament and habits.

at a glance, the two of them are 80% similar to teacher zhang.

song jia

haiqing

of course, if you look carefully, the two actors are slightly different.

haiqingthe character's face, demeanor and figure are even better, and his appearance is very similar to teacher zhang's.

song jia's demeanor and emotional expression are very similar to teacher zhang.

especially the dynamic between the eyebrows and eyes fits the character better and is a spiritual resemblance.

objectively speaking, it is commendable and impeccable for two non-typical actors to be so similar in appearance to the prototypes.

judging from the performance, one of the two is anxious, fast-paced, and full of artistic conception.

a slow one, with more details and more realistic.

《i am a mountain"" is a movie. it needs to express more content in a limited time. many plots are relatively compact and achieve effects directly through contradictions, so hai qing's performance is more direct.

for example, in the opening scene where principal zhang asks the children to go back to school, hai qing expresses it vigorously and pulls the students and parents without saying a word.

the voice is urgent, the expression is tense, the character is strong and unquestionable, and the dramatic tension is immediately apparent.

the drama version of song jia adopts a layer-by-layer approach.

at first, she was lying on the wall, with an anxious look on her face, and she was persuading the female students in a persuasive manner.

later, when facing parents, persuasion and fighting accounted for the majority of her arguments. she laid the foundation layer by layer, with sufficient details and strong appeal.

regarding the plot of preparing to build the school, the film version is very concise. the school is built almost from the beginning, and the difficulty of building the school is expressed through various details.

hai qing's performance focused on expressing anxiety and hard work, and the content of the story was very focused.

the drama version is much more detailed.

from the mental journey of starting the preparation, to meeting the big boss on the plane and telling him about the plan to attract investment, to tears at the conference, the process and difficulties of preparing the school are fully expressed.

when persuading the students to go back to school, haiqing's treatment of xiaoping's mother went from gentleness to reprimand to final comfort. the progression was very delicate, but the whole was very compact and the rhythm was fast.

the characters also work hard to highlight the softness on the outside and the hardness on the inside, and the emotional points are set densely and clearly.

song jia in the drama version appears much stronger. she wears a helmet and has a loud voice after entering the room. she not only protects the students, but also has the physical strength to confront the students' stubborn parents.

from the physical strength to the momentum, it is much more powerful, with many transitions, and there is no deliberate sensationalism.

in addition, there is also the plot of volunteering.

the film version shows teacher zhang guimei leading the students to watch the sunrise, telling the children that there is a wider world.

in the drama version, the teachers modified the children's wishes and wrote them on the blackboard with paint.

it can be seen that due to time constraints, the film version did not pursue narrative, but used intentional techniques to highlight the larger context and emotions.

the whole movie is more like a narrative poem, dominated by emotions.

hai qing's performance is also more about highlighting emotions and showing feelings, and uses more lens language, light and shadow to show the content.

the drama version, because it has more time and length, can tell the story completely and make the characters and plot more complete.

it is also more complete in expression.

song jia uses language, actions, and details to highly restore the characters, and his technique is more about telling the characteristics of the characters through stories.

song jia's performance is more realistic in the film, and thunder can be heard in the silent place.

these two ways of expression are determined by the characteristics of the film version and the drama version, and there is no distinction between them.

just look at hai qing andsong jiaeach performance has its own characteristics. even if they are compared together like this, it is difficult to say who is better than the other.

of course, from a scoring perspective, song jia seems to have a greater advantage.

due to various reasons, "i am a mountain" encountered a lot of doubts when it first aired, so much so that it has not yet been released on douban.

"when the mountain flowers are blooming" achieved a high score of 9.2 points and has an excellent reputation.

but the rating is more representative of the entire work, and the actor's performance cannot be equated with the work.

for example, in this year's feitian awards, the performance of "in the world", which has taken off in word-of-mouth ratings, was not nominated for the performances of several actresses. song jia also starred in the film.

in the masterpiece "the long season" which scored 9.4 points, none of the male actors were nominated for outstanding actor.

therefore, the quality of the work cannot completely equate to the quality of the actors.

hai qing and song jia are both excellent mesozoic actors, and they can even be classified in the same track.

in terms of awards, song jia has won the golden eagle, magnolia, golden rooster and other awards.

hai qing has also won awards such as the golden eagle and feitian.

song jia was born in 1980 and graduated from shanghai opera. in 2006, she won the golden rooster award for best supporting actress.

she has a bold personality, great performances, and is full of grandeur. she has worked with famous directors all the way, has many scandals, and is very powerful.

when cooperating with zhang li on "china's past"when zhang li's wife was an actress, there were rumors of an affair between the two.liu bei, and before that, zhang li had been married several times.

then, with the singerxie tianxiao, huang shaofeng and others have had scandals or relationships.

she has a free and easy personality and does not pursue marriage, but only pursues a happy life.

her performance has always been rich and colorful, with a sense of oppression. her performance in "when the mountain flowers are blooming" is very heavy, and almost every seemingly casual shot is full of connotation, and the small is the big.

she is in "curiosity killed the cat", "xiao hong", "cliff", "master" and other works, there are many classic shots, which can easily make people feel the charm of the performance and feel the acting skills, but they are very natural and not artificial.

cliff

master

hai qing's performance was external for a long time, with facial expressions greater than emotions.

haiqing was born in 1978 and graduated from nortel.huang leihis protégé, but because his appearance was not outstanding enough, his acting career was narrow and there were few opportunities when he was young, so he simply returned home to get married and have children.

when she came back, she starred in family dramas such as "the beautiful era of daughters-in-law", "double-sided tape" and "anna and wang gui", which established her status as a national daughter-in-law.

hai qing's performance is more life-like, and even a bit exaggerated in some places, but this is not a problem with her performance, but the needs of the role.

for a long time, hai qing has given people the impression that she is noisy, stingy, and has exaggerated acting skills.

however, after becoming famous, haiqing also deliberately got rid of this impression.

in "the summer of leslie cheung" she played the introverted and gentle dr. gu.

in "moses on the plain" she also plays the heroine with literary temperament.

with a gentle temperament and beautiful appearance, she feels completely different from her previous roles. in a sense, her acting skills are underestimated.

her temperament is more stable, gentle and restrained than song jia's.

back to the works, their different temperaments will inevitably lead to differences in the performances of the two works.

although hai qing acted freely, her overall performance was still reserved and restrained.

although song jia's performance is based on life, the overall temperament of her performance is still external and impactful.

when it comes to the character, this happens to be two sides of the same coin.

teacher zhang’s softness on the outside and hardness on the outside and softness on the inside are not in conflict. together, they express a complete character.

as for other disputes about the plot, comparison of details and even the determination of the overall tone, they do not entirely depend on the actors to a large extent, so they will not be discussed here.

which actor do you like and whose performance do you like?