news

한어Русский языкEnglishFrançaisIndonesianSanskrit日本語DeutschPortuguêsΕλληνικάespañolItalianoSuomalainenLatina

well-known teachers complain

the doctors specially recruited by the hospital are all college graduates.

who dares to see a doctor?

recently, a county in henan province released a list of candidates to be hired from the 2024 special recruitment of medical college graduates.since all the specially recruited doctors have a college degree, there are only a few with a bachelor's degree., which immediately aroused heated discussion among netizens.

the recruitment list was circulated on the internet and became a hot topic after many discussions. many internet celebrities also "the hospital recruited a bunch of college students"posted his own comments.

in a headline, lao wan, a well-known teacher in jiangxi, said: "it is incredible that the county hospital recruited so many college graduates as doctors. i am not looking down on college graduates.but if you entrust yourself to a classmate who couldn’t even get into undergraduate school, can you really feel at ease?isn’t it said that it’s difficult to find a job in medicine? why can’t i see that here? "

a self-media account that interprets medical policies in henan province even expressed its concerns in a post, saying: “i don’t know which hospitals these recruited college students will be assigned to, but i still feel unhappy that almost all of them are college students.medical knowledge is complex and college graduates do not fully master it. if they are employed directly, i think no one would dare to go to them for medical treatment. this recruitment list is also a special recruitment. i don’t know what the special recruitment is. is there any trick in it?”

complaints and doubts arose one after another, but some people also thought that there was no need to make a fuss, because no matter which hospital college students went to, they would have to find a job.

for example, a netizen from jiangsu disagreed with the tone that college graduates are not competent for clinical work. she pointed out: "those who question it still look down on college graduates in their hearts.in the past, technical secondary school students could become doctors, so why can’t college students become doctors now? are undergraduates better at treating patients than junior college students?i don't think so. it is important to keep the original intention of saving lives and healing the wounded. when you first enter the hospital, everyone doesn't know much. in fact, they are all the same. it mainly depends on the subsequent learning ability. having knowledge does not necessarily mean culture.please do not look down on college students. college students basically go to grassroots hospitals and are very hardworking. after years of polishing and training, they will become excellent.”

the recruited college students cannot go to the county hospital, but can only go to the township health center.

is there something fishy when it comes to “special recruitment”?

i am also very curious about the fact that most of the medical students specially recruited by the county and city are college graduates. where did this recruitment list come from? why did they recruit so many college graduates?is it true, as netizens say, that these specially recruited college students will eventually go to the county hospital?

after checking various documents and verifying, the author finally saw the original source of this employment list.

it turns out that on august 29, the ningling county health commission of shangqiu city issued an announcement to publicly announce the candidates for employment among the 2024 ningling county's specially recruited medical school graduates. the announcement period is: august 29, 2024 - september 6, 2024. the list of candidates for employment circulated on the internet came from here.

previously, on july 2, shangqiu city issued a special recruitment notice for medical school graduates.need to recruit 243 peopleaccording to the "opinions on continuing to implement the grassroots health talent project" (yu wei fa [2021] no. 1) and the "henan provincial public institutions open recruitment procedures" (yu ren she [2015] no. 55) jointly issued by the henan provincial health commission, the department of human resources and social security and other five departments, relevant arrangements have been made to implement the 2024 shangqiu city "special recruitment plan for medical school graduates" recruitment work.the specially recruited doctors will serve in public county-level medical institutions, township health centers (community health service centers) in various counties (cities and districts) in shangqiu city.

the benefits for specially recruited doctors are particularly good.if an employer has vacancies, it should give priority to solving the problem of recruiting special students, without being restricted by the service period; if an employer does not have vacancies, it can, within the total number of municipal and county public institutions, follow the principle of "special needs, special arrangements, matching people with numbers, retaining people with numbers, and canceling people with numbers" to include special recruitment program postgraduates, undergraduate students who go to township health centers, and special recruitment junior college students who have obtained a bachelor's degree in medicine into the talent establishment management.specific talent standards are formulated by local governments based on actual conditions.

priority is given to solving the staffing problem when recruiting special doctors. it is already a great achievement to have a staffing problem now. no wonder this list of candidates for employment has caused such a big discussion.so, which hospitals will these specially recruited college students go to?

according to the "list of job majors and number of special recruitment positions for medical college graduates in shangqiu city in 2024", ningling county was originally going to recruit so many college students.moreover, these college students cannot go to the county hospital, and the positions given to them are township health centers or community health service centers.

it suddenly dawned on me that it was normal to recruit so many college graduates, because grassroots hospitals needed them. they couldn't go to county hospitals, so they could only go to township health centers.primary hospitals are the most suitable places for doctors with college degrees to work. what's the big deal?

in addition, some people said that they worked hard to pass the postgraduate examination, but they were still just contract workers when they entered the hospital. why can those who were specially recruited easily get the regular positions? they were very angry and wondered if those who were recruited were all relatives of the hospital leaders? they suspected that there was something fishy going on.

so, what does special recruitment mean?

simply put, hospital special recruitment refers to medical institutions recruiting qualified medical talents through special channels or plans, with the aim of improving the quality of medical services, promoting the flow of medical talents, and meeting personalized medical needs.

the special recruitment process usually includespublish recruitment notices, registration and qualification review, examinations (written tests and interviews), physical examinations, inspections, public announcements and employmentand other links.

after recruitment, the provincial finance will provide compensatory subsidies to specially recruited medical students with bachelor's degrees or above.the standard is 9,500 yuan per year for graduate students, for three years; 6,000 yuan per year for undergraduates, for five years.as long as the employer has vacancies, priority should be given to recruiting specially recruited doctors, without any restrictions on service period.

the benefits are so good, so what is the purpose of special recruitment?

the reason is simple. some medical college graduates do not meet the general admission standards in terms of physical health, but their academic performance and medical literacy are excellent. in this case, they will be given opportunities through special recruitment. as for positions in primary medical and health units, some doctors are simply not retained. hospitals use special recruitment to ensure that the recruited talents can make long-term contributions to primary medical and health care during their service period.

so,you cannot think there is something fishy when you see the words "special recruitment". as long as the procedures are compliant and legal, open and transparent, and subject to supervision, there is nothing to blame even if the candidate has a college degree.

are college graduates not qualified to be doctors?

college doctors also have their place!

a list of candidates for recruitment can cause such a heated discussion. when you open the comment section of each post, you will see "college students cannot get treatment”“i don't dare to see a doctor from a college”“nowadays, colleges and universities also offer clinical majors”“it is a sheer waste of public resources that colleges and universities can apply for clinical majors."from these words, we can see the deep malice of netizens towards college students.

i really don't understand. if you study medicine in a junior college, you are inferior to others? are you not qualified to be a doctor?

it is understood that the number of medical graduates in my country has exceeded one million. on september 12, the director of the national health commissionlei haichaoat the press conference, it was introduced that the number of medical undergraduate (or above) graduates each year exceeds 500,000. it can be inferred that the number of medical vocational college graduates is also in the range of 400,000 to 500,000.

in fact, we can understand the discrimination of some netizens. with nearly half of the graduates from junior colleges, it is difficult for undergraduate clinical graduates to find jobs, not to mention junior college graduates. especially after the junior college graduates lost the possibility of becoming doctors in the law, in this medical circle where "everything is inferior except for high education", people began to speculate: will junior college graduates also be prohibited from taking the medical examination in the next step?

at present, doctors with secondary technical school education can be said to have been completely abandoned. after the reform and opening up, the government felt that secondary technical school education was not enough for doctors, so after the 1980s, secondary technical schools were merged and promoted to establish many medical colleges, which were dedicated to training high school graduates for three years. since then, a large number of medical schools have disappeared.

decades later, the technical secondary school doctors at that time have long since retired. in 2022, the "medical practitioners law of the people's republic of china" was revised, and those with secondary school medical degrees are no longer allowed to take the practicing physician qualification examination.

compared with secondary technical schools, junior colleges are one level higher. at that time, junior college students were scarce talents in the country, especially medical students. the admission score was not lower than that of undergraduate students. after graduation, the state assigned them jobs and they could directly enter the hospital. they had both decent income and stable jobs.

nowadays, college doctors from the 1980s are still active in the clinical frontline. referring to the development trajectory of technical secondary schools, as the enrollment of undergraduates is further expanded, people begin to worry:after the current college doctors retire, will the country not allow college students to take the medical examination in the future?

it is hard to say. based on this possibility, there is indeed discrimination against doctors with college degrees on the internet. people can say anything. but the author believes that since college clinical practice has been established, it is reasonable!

on august 29, the national health commission released the statistical bulletin on the development of my country's health care industry in 2023. according to the bulletin, by the end of 2023,there are 33,753 township health centers in china., 1.505 million beds,1.605 million health workerscompared with the previous year, the number of beds increased by 49,000 and the number of staff increased by 75,000.37,177 community health service centers (stations)，778,000 health workersthe number of health workers increased by 60,000 over the previous year.

the number of township health centers and community health service centers (stations) has exceeded 70,000, in contrast,there are only 38,355 hospitals in the country (11,772 of which are public hospitals and 26,583 are private hospitals).

please take a look at the number of township health centers and community health service centers across the country, and the gap in medical talent required is so huge.how many undergraduates are willing to go?it was so hard to get a graduate student here that he was even on the news. since undergraduates won’t go, college students will have to go. this is the significance of training college students. they fill the huge gap in primary medical talents.

as for the statement that people are afraid to see a college doctor, it is too exaggerated. at the grassroots level, a college degree is enough to deal with various common diseases! since doctors are technical workers,even if a doctor with a college degree enters a tertiary hospital, as long as he is willing to work hard and has strong hands-on ability, he can be competent, especially in surgery.please don't doubt this.in the fields of neurology, hepatobiliary, orthopedics, etc., there are a huge number of industry leaders who have college degrees, but this does not prevent them from becoming the best surgeons.

in summary, training college doctors has its own uses, and there is a place for college students in medical institutions at all levels.so, let’s put away our condescending tinted glasses!

written by | alaska treasure

editor | alaska treasure